top of page

Finding the Right Expert Witness: A Guide for Attorneys

Updated: Dec 3, 2025

Beware of C.V. Embellishers


Let’s be real, folks. When looking for an expert witness, be warned of C.V. embellishers, resume ‘padders,’ and ridiculous certification claims. You need to verify them!


Your expert witness should have courses that can be proven with more than just a generic certificate. They should have training that meets national and federal standards. Avoid courses given by unknown entities with flashy names on topics that sound exciting but are essentially a joke. For example, an 8-hour course on "Field Assault Sniper Tactical Handcuffing" is not what you need.


Your experts should be able to speak in detail about their chosen expertise. It should be clear they have real-world experience. They should have extensive training and also serve as trainers themselves. Look for experts trusted by legitimate law enforcement agencies, academic institutions, military commands, and government departments. There is no room for A.I. nonsense here!


The Importance of Practical Knowledge


It’s frustrating to see individuals who have put in the work, time, and effort to hone their craft overshadowed by those who merely regurgitate information from a class or course. These individuals lack practical knowledge and real-world application. You know what an expert can and cannot testify to, regardless of what their resume or C.V. states.


Don’t be fooled by flashy images of tactical gear, tight t-shirts, drop-down leg holsters, and thigh rigs. Avoid the ‘operator speak’ guys who seem eager to share insider information on social media.


Instead, look for an expert with easily verifiable information. Their courses and training should hold national and federal standards. An expert who has applied their knowledge in high-stakes situations is invaluable. Always check references for validity, not just written accolades with names withheld.


Building Trust with Your Expert


Keep in mind that a good expert will check you out too. They will listen for any inconsistencies in your claims, just as you should evaluate theirs. Trust is a two-way street in this relationship.


The Role of Experience


Experience matters. An expert who has faced real challenges will provide insights that a novice simply cannot. They understand the nuances of their field and can offer valuable perspectives that enhance your case.


Verifying Credentials


When you evaluate an expert, ensure their credentials are not just impressive on paper. Look for evidence of their experience in the field. Ask for case studies or examples of their work. This will help you gauge their ability to contribute effectively to your case.


The Value of Communication


Communication is key. An expert should be able to convey complex information clearly and concisely. They must be able to explain their findings in a way that is understandable to judges and juries alike.


Conclusion


In conclusion, finding the right expert witness is crucial for your case. Look for individuals with proven credentials, practical experience, and the ability to communicate effectively. Avoid those who rely on flashy presentations and questionable claims.


Check out my other posts for more "amazing" pro-tips and thoughts (wink).


OK, now let’s get back to fighting the good fight, shall we?

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
What makes a great expert witness?

An expert that has hundreds of hours of instructing and teaching can turn the courtroom into his/her classroom. I have always enjoyed instructing.  But find that I really enjoy looking around the cour

 
 
 
Interesting case/ shoddy cop work

Just wrapped up sitting as an advisory witness and Use of Force Expert for a case involving self defense. This case involved a person that was assaulted by their domestic partner.  During the assault

 
 
 
Understanding the Flaws in Arrest Control Programs

The Problem with Pre-Packaged Programs Law enforcement agencies often stick to their chosen arrest control programs. But why? Many of these "one-stop-shop" programs rely on questionable concepts. Take

 
 
 

Comments


By the Brooks Agency Logo - Black.png

Phone: (303) 669-6869

Colorado, USA

By the Brooks Agency is not a law firm, therefore does not offer legal
advice but rather offers legal opinion.


By the Brooks Agency is owned and operated by Matthew Brooks a retired
31-year law enforcement veteran. Matthew is an S.M.E. (Subject Matter
Expert) in Use of Force, Search and Seizure as well as tactical operations
of Police /SWAT.


By the Brooks Agency will provide a professional interpretation of the 4th
amendment and its application through extensive law enforcement training, 
experience and continuing education while referencing case law studies pertaining to use of force / search and seizure.

© 2025 by By the Brooks Agency

bottom of page