top of page

Interesting case/ shoddy cop work

Just wrapped up sitting as an advisory witness and Use of Force Expert for a case involving self defense. This case involved a person that was assaulted by their domestic partner. 


During the assault the victim in this case used taught self-defense techniques to defend themselves. 911 was called, by the victim. 


Responding deputies conducted and "investigation" as to who was going to be arrested. The deputies used terms like 'predominate aggressor' and 'flip of the coin' as deciding factors! 


The deputies decided to arrest the victim for the assault with a domestic violence enhancer because a common part of the incident was that the victim pushed the 'attacker' away. 


I was easily able to relate to the jury and could tell that they wanted to hear my testimony (2 hours worth). I explained that 'predominate aggressor' (defined) is NOT a thing and that what IS used is 'primary aggressor' (also defined). I explained that 'probable cause' (defined) is NEVER decided by a 'flip of the coin!'


It was also my pleasure to educate the jury in use of force and the reasonableness standard. I also was able to educate the jury in self defense (UoF) that includes 'proportionate' in response and non-retaliatory.



Worked with a fantastic law firm (not sure if they would want a plug or not so name withheld), great lawyers and legal assistance personnel. 



End result- Not guilty on ALL charges.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Understanding the Flaws in Arrest Control Programs

The Problem with Pre-Packaged Programs Law enforcement agencies often stick to their chosen arrest control programs. But why? Many of these "one-stop-shop" programs rely on questionable concepts. Take

 
 
 
Choose Wisely

Have you ever tried to teach someone else’s lesson plan and power point, on short notice?  Even if you know the material, in general, you will be ‘off your game’!  Your timing will be way off.  You mi

 
 
 

Comments


By the Brooks Agency Logo - Black.png

Phone: (303) 669-6869

Colorado, USA

By the Brooks Agency is not a law firm, therefore does not offer legal
advice but rather offers legal opinion.


By the Brooks Agency is owned and operated by Matthew Brooks a retired
31-year law enforcement veteran. Matthew is an S.M.E. (Subject Matter
Expert) in Use of Force, Search and Seizure as well as tactical operations
of Police /SWAT.


By the Brooks Agency will provide a professional interpretation of the 4th
amendment and its application through extensive law enforcement training, 
experience and continuing education while referencing case law studies pertaining to use of force / search and seizure.

© 2025 by By the Brooks Agency

bottom of page